Friends, imagine this situation. You have a terrible headache, so you go to the doctor. He silently examines you, runs some tests, but doesn’t ask a single question. You can’t say anything either—because he told you to keep your mouth shut.
When the results come in, he sees high protein levels, low hemoglobin, and kidney issues. So he starts treating all of that… even though you came to him because your head hurts. But you can’t tell him that.
That’s pretty much what happens in most pitch sessions.
You send your synopsis—and remain silent. The specialist (in this case, the executive or consultant) reads it and gives feedback. But they don’t ask:
“What’s your goal?”
“What genre are you writing in?”
“Why does this moment matter?”
“Why does your character act that way?”
“Why is their emotional depth on this level and not deeper—or lighter?”
And I believe a screenwriter should explain these things. Maybe some of it wasn’t clearly written in the synopsis—that’s easy to fix. But it doesn’t mean you have to rewrite two-thirds of your entire film.
Because when a consultant gives feedback based only on the synopsis, you often end up rewriting the story, losing your voice, your vision, and even your story. You start writing what others want instead of what you wanted to say.
What do you think—am I right or not?
3 people like this
Hi, Ianna R Miolan-Cruz! It depends for me. If I'm writing a script with roles that can be played by anyone, I don't mention race. If race is important to the story, I put it in the character descript...
Expand commentHi, Ianna R Miolan-Cruz! It depends for me. If I'm writing a script with roles that can be played by anyone, I don't mention race. If race is important to the story, I put it in the character description(s).
1 person likes this
It helps unless there is a special phrase you can use to distinguish the characters. But for those who are not familiar with that country's people.
You need to be careful with this. If you specify a characters race for no apparent reason, it can create the perception you see all other characters as white by default. It's best to keep things open ended.
Concur with CJ, above. I'd also double-down on the specifyying for no apparent reason -- there really shouldn't be any detail in your script that's specified without any reason. This leads to loose, r...
Expand commentConcur with CJ, above. I'd also double-down on the specifyying for no apparent reason -- there really shouldn't be any detail in your script that's specified without any reason. This leads to loose, random, aimless writing. Obviously, if a character's race is fundamentally significant to your story (egs. Solomon Northup in 12 Years a Slave; Mollie Burkhart in Killers of the Flower Moon; Chris Washington in Get Out) then you should state as it's essential.