There is something I keep finding genuinely fascinating as I talk to more people about Echoes of Asgard. The moment I mention Thor, Odin or Loki, some people already have an idea in their head of what I must be making. I understand why. These names have been part of popular entertainment for years, and Marvel built an enormously successful interpretation that introduced them to an audience far beyond the people who were already interested in Norse mythology.
The strange part for me is how quickly familiarity can sometimes close somebody's curiosity instead of opening it. I am not trying to compete with Marvel's interpretation of Thor. They built their world, their characters and their relationships around the stories they wanted to tell. Echoes of Asgard is coming from a completely different direction. I have spent years going back through the mythology, the surviving material, the historical questions, the relationships between these figures and the civilization that would have to exist around them for our story to work.
What makes this especially interesting is that our industry accepts reinterpretation constantly. We have had zombies that walk, zombies that run, zombies that retain intelligence, zombies caused by viruses, fungi, science, supernatural events and almost everything in between. We have watched Batman interpreted in radically different tones. Dracula has been horror, romance, tragedy and action. Robin Hood has been revisited again and again. Sherlock Holmes has lived in multiple periods and genres. We regularly take an idea people recognize and ask what happens when another filmmaker looks at it differently.
Somehow mythology can occasionally receive a different reaction. People hear Thor and think they already understand Thor. They hear Loki and immediately understand his relationship with Thor through a modern interpretation. They hear Odin and picture the version of Odin they already know. That is where I find myself wanting to ask people to slow down for a minute, because the surviving Norse material is considerably stranger, richer and often very different from what popular culture has taught most of us.
Thor and Loki are a perfect example. The familiar brother relationship is not the relationship found in the Norse sources. Thor's mother is Jƶrư, which opens an entirely different conversation around his lineage. Sif, Thor's children, Loki's relationship with Odin, the meaning attached to Mjƶlnir and even the social roles surrounding these figures give us far more to work with than the simplified versions most people encounter first. Odin becomes increasingly complicated the further you dig into him. Loki becomes much harder to reduce to one convenient role. Thor becomes much more interesting to me once strength is placed beside responsibility, family, leadership and the people who depend on him.
That research eventually changed the way I was writing the world itself. I started asking what Asgard actually looks like if I treat it as a civilization before I treat it as mythology. Who grows the food? Who maintains the roads? How does trade work? Where do soldiers train? What does authority look like outside the throne room? What does a prince actually owe the people walking into battle behind him? When somebody becomes a legend generations later, what kind of person existed before the stories became larger than the life?
Those questions are why Echoes has grown into far more than the original scripts. We are building and testing Asgard in Unreal. We are working through previs, cinematography, movement, geography and the practical questions of how locations function before physical production begins. The characters have actual arcs across the series. The novel gives me another way to explore the world. The audiobook is coming. The proof of concept is being developed. The actors are being brought into the character work early enough to understand where these people came from and where they are going.
Perhaps part of the problem is simply that I have tried to explain too much of this inside pitch meetings and conversations where there is never enough time. Eight minutes disappears incredibly quickly when somebody needs the premise, the characters, the world, the production direction, the audience opportunity and some understanding of what makes the project commercially interesting. I can improve at that. I also realized that I needed somewhere where people who were genuinely curious could go beyond those eight minutes.
That is a major reason I built echoes-of-asgard.com. I wanted somebody to be able to actually explore what I mean instead of taking my word for it. The series is there. The character work is there. The civilization and worldbuilding are there. The research is there. The production development is there. Industry information is there. I would rather somebody spend time looking through what has been built and then come back with difficult questions than make a decision based entirely on hearing three famous names and assuming they already know the project.
I also think there is a business question buried inside all of this. Familiarity can be extremely valuable. Thor, Odin, Loki and Norse mythology already generate enormous curiosity around the world. That gives us an entry point. My responsibility is to prove that once people walk through that door, Echoes itself gives them a reason to stay. That is what I am trying to demonstrate through the story, the characters, the audience building, the website, the novel, the audiobook and eventually the proof of concept.
If you work in producing, development or distribution, I would especially like your perspective. When a project begins with mythology or characters that already carry enormous cultural recognition, does that existing familiarity make you see an audience opportunity, or does the popularity of previous interpretations make you more hesitant to look at what another creator is actually doing with the source material?
And if you think you already know Thor, Odin and Loki, how much would have to surprise you before you wanted to know more?
1 person likes this
Hey Ashley Renée Smith I'm all signed up for the meeting. Here's my Confirmation #ILL09HETG
Thank you, MB!
1 person likes this
Registered, added to the diary, set an alarm and shared across both Facebook and Instagram telling people to get themselves on here and take a chance! Can't wait to join my first one! Thanks again Ashley! - Mark
1 person likes this
Registered and shared a link to the session on Facebook screening group.
1 person likes this
Registered! Shared it with two screenwriter friends! Looking forward to this!
You're welcome, Ashley RenƩe Smith. I got the code. Thanks. Yeah, I found out that maintaining relationships is really important in the film and TV industries....
Expand commentYou're welcome, Ashley Renée Smith. I got the code. Thanks. Yeah, I found out that maintaining relationships is really important in the film and TV industries.