Adaptations Part One: Books
What have you noticed about your favorite adaptation? What things were left out? Added in? Combined? Simplified? And if you helmed it, what would you have done?
Books are probably the most popular type. The story is there, so are the characters, and a popular book already has hype. However, it can often be surprising just how an even popular story is adapted. For example, the book Jaws and its popular screen adaptation has most of the tropes. Most of the subplots have been simplified or not included. The backstory is greatly simplified to focus on the here and now. However, all this makes the book and movie quite different.
For one, the book was intended for adults, though it’s not strictly objectionable for teens. I read it in 7th grade, but I was surprised how different it was from the movie. For example, Chief Brody is a recovering alcoholic, thus his job in the small town of Amity is a reassignment from a bigger city and precinct. The Mayor is eager to keep the beaches open not just for seasonal business, but because he also owes the mob money. Matt Hooper, the scientist trying to track the shark, goes for a friendly dinner at Brody’s house in the movie, but in the book he has an affair with Brody’s wife. And the now legendary “Indianapolis monologue” is not in the book, since it was improvised on set by Robet Shaw who played Quint. Also, in the book Quint swears all the time. The movie simplifies all of this and goes down to a PG rating from what would have been an easy R even back in 1975.
Other adaptations, such as the more recent Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter, and Game of Thrones series also take much bulkier books and streamline the screenstory.
However, on the flipside, there are books like Fight Club which is actually quite short at just over 200 pages, yet the film is long clocking in at 2 hours 19 minutes. The film captures most of the book, yet also streamlines the plot to a more dramatic conclusion.
-----
Next week: Graphic Novels
What producers are looking for a "scalability engine"?