So the inside story on the dead Buffy reboot is out, and honestly, it's a mess. Sarah Michelle Gellar was finally on board, Oscar winner Chloé Zhao was directing, Hulu ordered a pilot... and then last Friday, they pulled the plug. No series order. No chance to fix it further. Just dead.
What's wild is the details. The first cut of the pilot apparently played "too young" and felt "small." The writers did a rewrite that everyone thought fixed it—more Gellar, more adult, more like a streaming show. Studios were happy. Then the Hulu exec called at 6pm on a Friday to kill it. Gellar found out while stepping onto a red carpet for another movie produced by the same company.
And here's the kicker: Gellar publicly called out an executive who reportedly told people he'd never watched the original Buffy and "was proud to remind us" it wasn't for him. That executive? The one who made the final call.
For anyone developing projects, this is both terrifying and instructive. You can have the IP, the star, the Oscar-winning director, a pilot in the can—and still get killed because one decision-maker doesn't connect with the material. Or because budgets shifted. Or because the rewrite that fixed everything suddenly made it "too expensive."
It's a reminder that development is fragile. Nothing is real until cameras are rolling on a season order. And sometimes, even then...
Does this make you more cautious about attaching your heart to a project, or does it just reinforce that you have to keep pushing regardless?
1 person likes this
That's shocking, Sam Rivera! I thought for sure the Buffy reboot would happen. It reinforces that I have to keep pushing regardless. I've had producers pass on my projects, then other producers were interested in them and requested them months and years later. I've gotten a lot better at not attaching my heart to projects since I know the scripts will probably change once I sell them/once I finish ghostwriting them.
2 people like this
I can’t imagine Buffy without Joss Whedon, and of course I can’t imagine Joss Whedon working again.
Sounds like we may have dodged a bullet here. I think the show shouldn’t move forward if it’s not very good. And the executive who never watched the original? That might give him a fine perspective for judging a current show that should have modern qualities.
That said,I’m hoping for a leak so I can watch the pilot and judge for myself!
2 people like this
I was so looking forward to this reboot! Hopefully they rework it and it comes back someday. Maybe one of our Stage 32 members will craft a stronger concept.
As a younger fan of the show, I'm disappointed that I won't yet get to experience watching a Buffy episode premiere. However, from what I've heard, it seems like they may have made the right decision. I personally can't imagine what the show would be like without Spike or Angel. Unless the project was willing to spend resources on digitally altering their appearances to keep them young. Same thing goes for SMG. Would the relationship drama side plots continue? It's hard to keep a show as iconic as Buffy the same 20 years later. It's a story about a teenage girl coming to understand her role as both the slayer and as a woman. For me, a continuation of Buffy's life story would only work with a completely original perspective/framework, but this also effectively makes it a spin off, rather than a "reboot."
Great discussion. As a writer and actress, I focus on building emotionally driven stories with strong characters and high-stakes conflicts. Currently developing a series with international scope.
I was disappointed to hear that a Buffy reboot wouldn't happen. I was a fan of the show when I was a pre teen and teen.
It goes to show you even when all the cards fall correctly, sometimes things don't work out...I'm sure it was frustrating.
No.
1 person likes this
It shows that rejections happen at every level and stage, and there's a solidarity in that. We just have to keep believing and pushing for the yes's!
Hulu killed it because they thought it wasn't good enough to justify the high cost, much of which would've been SGM's salary. Basically she over-played her hand when negotiating her pay.